Which product is more effective for Menopausal Symptoms – – black cohosh or soy based products or Royal Maca?

 

Cert. Org. Pre-cooked

Royal Maca®

Phytoestrogenic Herbs/Botanicals
Wild Yam/Natural Progesterone Cream
Definitions: A cruciferous* root vegetable with adaptogenic properties.  That’s why maca can help women’s PMS & menopausal symptoms and also support men’s libido & erectile function. Herbs that contain chemical compounds which attach to estrogen receptors & act like weak estrogens.(Black Cohosh, Red Clover, Soy, Dong Quai, etc.) Chemical compounds from the wild yam plant, changed in lab to replicate chemical structure of human progesterone.
Menopausal Symptoms
  • Mild Hot Flashes
highly effective generally effective can be helpful
  • Severe Hot Flashes
highly effective in atleast 75% of women generally not effective generally not effective
  • Brain Fog
highly effective generally not effective generally not effective
  • Menopausal Depression
highly effective generally effective helpful in some cases
  • Loss of Libido
often highly effective generally not effective generally not effective
  • Vaginal Dryness
generally very effective generally not effective generally not effective
Alleviates PMS Symptoms
  • Headache
highly effective sometimes not effective sometimes not effective
  • Depression
highly effective sometimes not effective sometimes not effective
  • Tender Breasts
highly effective sometimes not effective sometimes not effective
  • Supports Menstrual Regularity
highly effective not effective not effective
  • Supports Painless-Low Pain Menstrual Periods
highly effective sometimes effective sometimes effective
Support Healthy Thyroid Function often effective not effective not effective
Support Energy & Stamina generally effective not effective not effective
Supports Healthy Aging in Men
  • Increases libido
generally effective not effective not effective
  • Increases Erectile Function
generally effective not effective not effective
  • Support Energy/Stamina
generally effective not effective not effective

*Cruciferous: vegetables belonging to the Brassica family contain indole 3 carbinole, which promotes healthy estrogen metabolism.